My Honest Review of SUPERGIRL: Mostly Enjoyable. Milly Alcock soars high as Kara Zor-El !

By: Edgar Allan E. Yu 

SUPERGIRL, based on the comic book Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow, offers a fresh and compelling take that sets it apart from any previous film or TV adaptations. This is definitely not just a female version of Superman. Instead, Kara Zor-El is portrayed as a messy party girl—often drunk and far from the typical role-model archetype. Yet, beneath that chaotic exterior lies a tough, super-strong heroine carrying a heavy emotional burden.

Milly Alcock shines brilliantly as Supergirl, bringing a likeable, brave, and unpredictable energy to the character that truly soars. Her portrayal captures the complexity of Kara Zor-El in a way that feels authentic and engaging. David Corenswet’s Kal-El adds depth to the story, embodying the noble traits of Superman with genuine warmth, and their interactions create some of the film’s most memorable moments. Eve Ridley delivers a powerful performance as Ruthye, a character driven by trauma and revenge, while Jason Momoa embraces the role of Lobo with infectious enthusiasm, clearly enjoying every moment. And let’s not forget Krypto—the cutest companion who deserves even more screen time. The fight scenes are well-executed and thrilling, and the flashbacks to Krypton add a visually delightful layer to the narrative.

However, the film isn’t without its flaws. The main villain, Krem of the Yellow Hills, played by Mathias Schoenaerts, feels disappointingly generic and lacks the impact one would expect from a comic-book antagonist. Additionally, director Craig Gillespie and screenwriter Ana Nogueira’s departure from the source material results in a story that misses some of the profound emotional depth found in the original comic.

Despite these shortcomings, SUPERGIRL remains a mostly enjoyable experience. It successfully introduces a complex, flawed, and compelling new version of Kara Zor-El, anchored by Milly Alcock’s standout performance. Fans and newcomers alike can look forward to seeing this Supergirl rise to even greater heights in future installments.

#SUPERGIRL

Photo credits: Warner Bros Pictures